Brattleboro Selectboard Agenda and Notes – November 17, 2026

The Town Manager is asking for permission to sign a lease to start the process of possibly moving out of the Municipal Center and down the street to the Holstein Association building.  He’s presenting this plan to the selectboard at their next regular meeting with information about the impact to town operations. Not included is mention of the impact to the other major, long-term tenants of the Municipal Center  – BCTV and the Brattleboro Historical Society.

The board has been discussing the move in a series of executive sessions.

…..

The Brattleboro Selectboard will hold a meeting on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, at 6:15pm in the Selectboard Meeting Room at the Brattleboro Municipal Center (230 Main Street, Room 212) and over Zoom.  Prior to the regular meeting, at 5:30pm the Board will convene to hold committee interviews with applicants for the Human Services Committee. Interviews are open to the public. The attached agenda contains information on how to access the meeting remotely, including the required “passcode.”  Closed captioning will be available for deaf and hard-of-hearing community members. The backup materials for this meeting will be available on the town website by the end of the day

Jessica Sticklor (she/her/hers)

Executive Assistant

Town of Brattleboro

230 Main Street, Suite 208

Brattleboro, VT 05301

(802) 251 – 8115

 

BRATTLEBORO SELECTBOARD
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17, 2026
SELECTBOARD MEETING ROOM + ZOOM
COMMITTEE INTERVIEWS – 5:30 PM
REGULAR MEETING – 6:15 PM

The physical location for this meeting will be the Selectboard Meeting Room at the Municipal Center
at 230 Main Street. Selectboard Meeting materials can be found on the Town’s website, Brattleboro.gov/Selectboard.

Join Zoom Meeting

https://us02web.zoom.us/j/87922316377?pwd=nL9cJ77I3UpEyLXGmPosNEjAh5BbgK.1

Meeting ID: 879 2231 6377

Passcode: 492979

One tap mobile

+19292056099,,87922316377#,,,,492979# US (New York)

+13017158592,,87922316377#,,,,492979# US (Washington DC)

Join by SIP

• 87922316377@zoomcrc.com

Join instructions

https://us02web.zoom.us/meetings/87922316377/invitations?signature=0zKTxk0_BBSU-

gWl2nM4cSnr1EaPEVoL0dVnlu3Uabg

AGENDA

ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT

(please note that all times indicated are approximate)

1. CONVENE REGULAR MEETING (6:15 PM)

2. ADJUSTMENTS TO AGENDA

3. APPROVE MINUTES –

4. CHAIR’S REMARKS

5. MANAGER’S COMMENTS

6. SELECTBOARD COMMENTS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS

7. OPEN PUBLIC COMMENT (6:30 PM)

8. CONSENT AGENDA

A. Dollar General Tobacco Substitute Endorsement Permit – Approve

B. Turning Point 5K Parade Permit Application – Approve

C. Red Clover Rovers Turkey Trot Parade Permit Application – Approve

9. REGULAR BUSINESS (6:35 PM)

A. FY27 Budget Update Through September Quarterly Report (6:35 PM)
Presentation by Finance Staff

B. Fire Department Quarterly Review (6:55 PM)
Presentation by Fire Department Staff

C. Holstein Building Lease Option / Municipal Center Future (7:15 PM)
Presentation by Town Staff

D. FY28 General Fund Budget Development (8:00 PM)
Presentation by Town Staff

E. Human Services Committee Appointments (9:00 PM)
Appointments Made by Selectboard

10. CORRESPONDENCE

A. Warrants, Department Reports, and Correspondence

11. ADJOURNMENT (9:15 PM)

….

MEMORANDUM

To: Selectboard

From: John Potter, Town Manager

Re: Administrative Report

Date: November 13, 2026

——————————–

The following will summarize the proposed motions for the Selectboard meeting on Tuesday, November 17,
2026. The Board will convene the meeting at 6:15pm in the Selectboard Meeting Room and on Zoom. All
times listed below are approximate, and interested parties should monitor the meeting if they do not want to miss an agenda item.

Join Zoom Meeting

https://us02web.zoom.us/j/87922316377?pwd=nL9cJ77I3UpEyLXGmPosNEjAh5BbgK.1

Meeting ID: 879 2231 6377

Passcode: 492979

One tap mobile

+19292056099,,87922316377#,,,,492979# US (New York)

+13017158592,,87922316377#,,,,492979# US (Washington DC)

Join by SIP

• 87922316377@zoomcrc.com

Join instructions

https://us02web.zoom.us/meetings/87922316377/invitations?signature=0zKTxk0_BBSU-

gWl2nM4cSnr1EaPEVoL0dVnlu3Uabg

CONSENT AGENDA

Dollar General Tobacco Substitute Endorsement Permit – Approve

Turning Point 5K Parade Permit Application – Approve

Red Clover Rovers Turkey Trot Parade Permit Application – Approve

In a memorandum dated November 17, 2026, Town Clerk Hilary Francis discusses the Tobacco Substitute Endorsement Permit application for Dollar General Store #12210, located at 23 Marlboro Road. Town Staff have reviewed and recommend approval of this permit. By approving the Consent Agenda, the Board will approve a Tobacco Substitute Endorsement Permit for Dollar General Store #12210, located at 23 Marlboro Road.

In a memorandum dated November 13, 2026, Town Manager John Potter discusses the parade permit request for the Red Clover Rover’s Annual Turnkey Trot. The parade will be held on Thursday, November 26, 2026, from 9:00am to 10:30am. No road closures are required. By approving the Consent Agenda, the Board will approve a parade permit for the Red Clover Rovers Turkey Trot to be held on Thursday, November 26, 2026.

In a memorandum dated November 13, 2026, Town Manager John Potter discusses Turning Point Center for Windham County’s parade permit application for a 5K race to be held on April 24, 2027, from 9:00am to 12:00pm. No street closures are required. By approving the Consent Agenda, the Board will approve a parade permit for Turning Point Center of Windham County’s 5K race to be held on April 24, 2027.

POTENTIAL MOTION: TO ACCEPT THE CONSENT AGENDA, AS PRESENTED.

REGULAR BUSINESS (6:35 PM)

FY27 Budget Update Through September Quarterly Report (6:35 PM)

Presentation by Finance Staff

In a memorandum dated November 13, 2026, Finance Director SerahRose Bissell discusses the FY27 Budget Update through September.

POTENTIAL MOTION: NO MOTIONED IS REQUIRED FOR THIS ITEM.

Fire Department Quarterly Review (6:55 PM)

Presentation by Fire Department Staff

In a memorandum dated November 6, 2026, Fire Chief Peter Lynch discusses the Fire Department’s Quarterly Report for FY27 Quarter 1.

POTENTIAL MOTION: NO MOTIONED IS REQUIRED FOR THIS ITEM.

Holstein Building Lease Option / Municipal Center Future (7:15 PM)

Presentation by Town Staff

In a memorandum dated November 13, 2026, Town Manager John Potter presents an overview of the Municipal Center’s ongoing maintenance, code compliance, and long-term space needs and outlines a potential alternative in the Holstein Association USA building at One Holstein Place. The approach proposed in the memo would reserve the Holstein space while the Town continues evaluating its options, with further financial analysis, renovation estimates, and a proposed sale of the Municipal Center to be brought forward for consideration.

POTENTIAL MOTION: TO AUTHORIZE THE TOWN MANAGER TO EXECUTE AN OPTION TO LEASE SPACE IN THE HOLSTEIN ASSOCIATION USA BUILDING AT ONE HOLSTEIN PLACE, SUBJECT TO FINAL REVIEW BY THE TOWN ATTORNEY. THE OPTION WOULD RESERVE THE SPACE WHILE THE TOWN EVALUATES THE FUTURE OF THE MUNICIPAL CENTER AND THE PROPOSAL AND CONTINUES NEGOTIATIONS.

FY28 General Fund Budget Development (8:00 PM)

Presentation by Town Staff

In a memorandum dated November 13, 2026, Town Manager John Potter discusses the FY28 General Fund Budget.

POTENTIAL MOTION: NO MOTION IS REQUIRED FOR THIS ITEM.

Human Services Committee Appointments (9:00 PM)

Appointments Made by Selectboard

In a memorandum dated November 13, 2026, Town Manager John Potter discusses the Human Services appointment process and explains that the Board has scheduled committee interviews with the eleven applicants to the Human Services Committee. The Board is asked to appoint seven members to the Human Services Committee.

BOARD ACTION: TO NOMINATE, VOTE ON, AND APPOINT, SEVEN MEMBERS TO THE HUMAN SERVICES COMMITTEE.

Comments | 1

  • Here's the packet materials about the moving plans...

    MEMORANDUM

    To: Brattleboro Selectboard
    From: John Potter, Town Manager
    Dan Tyler, DPW Director
    Peter Lynch, Fire Chief
    Date: November 13, 2026
    Subject: Holstein Building Lease Option / Municipal Center Future

    Staff Recommendation
    Staff requests Selectboard consideration of this matter and action in the form of the following
    motion:

    Authorize the Town Manager to execute an option to lease space in the Holstein
    Association USA building at One Holstein Place, subject to final review by the Town
    Attorney. The option would reserve the space while the Town evaluates the future of the
    Municipal Center and the proposal and continues negotiations.

    Background

    The Town has been addressing the condition and long-term use of the Municipal Center at 230
    Main Street for at least a decade. In 2016, the Selectboard awarded a $110,000 sprinkler contract
    as part of its life-safety improvement plan. Additional life safety code violations have yet to be
    resolved. In 2017, the Board authorized lease negotiations with the State, whose tenancy could
    have helped fund renovations. In 2019, the Town announced a potential partnership with
    Windham & Windsor Housing Trust to combine municipal offices and housing in the building.
    The Board authorized feasibility work and up to $50,000 in Town Program Income through a
    forgivable loan. The concept advanced to specifications and a cost estimate but did not proceed
    to construction.

    A 2021 appraisal reports 32,912 square feet and separately describes a full basement and 3,680
    square feet of attic storage. The building exceeds the Town’s current space needs, and its aging
    systems still require substantial repairs, code improvements, and capital investment.
    Over the past year, the Town has evaluated several alternative locations to see whether municipal
    services could be delivered in a smaller space. The Holstein proposal offers that possibility.

    The Holstein Building
    The Holstein building on lower Main Street would keep municipal offices downtown while
    allowing the Town to adapt existing office space to its needs. Discussions with Holstein
    Association USA and the Selectboard have occurred in executive session; the proposal is now
    being presented publicly.

    Page 58 of 202

    The following is a high-level summary of the proposed lease framework. Terms remain under
    negotiation, and the lease documents are not included with this meeting’s materials.
    Space and parking: Approximately 16,695 rentable square feet of top-floor office space,
    1,000 square feet of basement storage, and use of 37 parking spaces, including at least
    one accessible space. Final boundaries, measurements, public access, and departmental
    layouts remain to be confirmed.

    Rent and term: Proposed initial full-rate base rent is approximately $277,120 annually, or
    $23,093 monthly, with 3% annual increases. The proposed initial term is 10 years, with 5
    five-year renewal options. Renewal rent would be determined under the final agreement.
    A reduced rent period during preparation is also proposed, with timing and conditions
    under negotiation.

    Building responsibilities: Holstein would maintain the building structure and major
    systems, including the roof, foundation, HVAC, electrical, and plumbing systems, and
    provide heat, water, grounds maintenance, and snow removal during normal business
    hours. The Town would pay for electricity, communications and data services, cleaning,
    waste removal, and tenant-assigned repairs.

    Improvements and future purchase opportunities: The Town would fund and manage the
    improvements needed for municipal use. The current draft assigns Holstein responsibility
    for required asbestos abatement arising from approved renovations. It also includes a
    right of first refusal if Holstein contracts to sell the building, providing a possible
    purchase opportunity without obligating the Town to buy.

    Holstein Building Renovations and Funding

    Although currently configured as office space. Updates and renovations would be necessary to
    adapt the Holstein space for municipal operations. Preliminary calculations estimate the
    renovations costs at $700,000. The intent would be to use proceeds from selling 230 Main Street
    to fund renovations at Holstein. Martin Appraisal Services valued the leased-fee interest at $1.97
    million as of June 2, 2021, subject to assumptions about the property’s condition. An updated
    valuation would inform the sale and funding plan. An $800,000 sale price figure is a planning
    assumption. Final costs must address design, construction, technology, furniture, moving,
    transaction costs, and contingency before determining whether net proceeds are sufficient.
    Town Meeting authorization to sell would not immediately make sale proceeds available.

    Marketing, negotiation, buyer due diligence, and closing could create a gap between approval and
    receipt of funds. Staff will need a coordinated sale, renovation, and occupancy schedule and an
    authorized funding source for any expenses incurred before closing. Any proposal to begin work
    before the sale is complete would need specific approval and appropriate contractual protection.
    Borrowing could be considered if sale proceeds are delayed or insufficient. For scale, borrowing
    the full $700,000 over 10 years at an assumed 4.5%, with equal annual principal and declining
    interest, would require approximately $101,500 in the first full repayment year, declining to
    $73,150 in the final year. Average annual payments would be approximately $87,325, with total
    interest of $173,250. This is an alternative financing illustration, not a quoted rate.

    At the proposed initial full-rate rent, rent plus first-year debt service under this borrowing scenario
    would total approximately $378,620, before Town-paid operating expenses.

    Page 59 of 202

    A sale for taxable private use could return 230 Main Street to the tax roll. At an assessed value of
    $1.2 million, it would generate approximately $20,600 annually in municipal property taxes. If a
    purchaser renovates the building, the assessed value will reflect those improvements and could
    generate additional ongoing tax revenue. Actual revenue would depend on the property’s taxable
    use, assessed value, and the tax rate in effect at the time.
    Municipal Center, 230 Main Street
    Staff have taken a high-level look at two possible approaches to renovation of the current
    Municipal Center. One option would identify code-related work and systems in need of upgrade.
    The second includes full renovation, including space reconfiguration. The preliminary comparison
    identifies approximately $4.5 million for necessary repairs and code-related work, or
    approximately $10 million for full renovation, repairs, space reconfiguration, and code
    compliance. Either approach could disrupt operations during construction, which could cause
    additional costs to be incurred. The full renovation option includes space reconfiguration, which
    makes additional space available and may lead to the possibility of future lease income.
    For planning illustrations, debt estimates assume full borrowing over 20 years at 4.5% with level
    annual debt service. Financing structure, issuance costs, and post-renovation operations could
    change the figures.

    Illustrative annual cost Necessary repairs Full renovation
    Project borrowing $4,500,000 $10,000,000
    Annual debt service $345,943 $768,761
    FY28 operating allowance $121,300 $121,300
    Combined annual cost $467,243 $890,061
    Net if $13,750 rent continues $453,493 $876,311

    The earlier housing partnership advanced to outline specifications and a February 2021
    construction estimate of $9.47 million for a mixed-use redevelopment, with municipal offices on
    the first floor and in the basement and housing on the upper floors. The estimate excluded
    hazardous-material testing and abatement and did not include an owner’s contingency. It reflects
    the earlier mixed-use scope and is separate from today’s planning scenarios.
    The proposed FY28 budget includes $121,300 for basic operations and routine maintenance,
    before any capital work.

    Lease Option
    Staff requests authorization to enter a lease option that would reserve the Holstein space until after
    Town Meeting. If the Town executes the option and continues pursuing Holstein, an article would
    go before Town Meeting seeking approval to sell 230 Main Street. The proposed FY28 budget
    would be updated to reflect anticipated lease and operating costs. Staff would return to the
    Selectboard with refined renovation costs, any request for borrowing or interim funding, and a
    plan for coordinating the sale and move.

    Page 60 of 202

    Staying at 230 Main Street carries financial risk even if the Town does not undertake renovation.
    The operating budget covers routine costs, and the Town does not currently have capital funds for
    the improvements the building needs. A major system failure could require spending well beyond
    the operating budget. After many years of pursuing options and cost savings at 230 Main St., the
    Holstein building provides a smaller space, would better serve residents and staff, and put the
    Town’s facility costs on a more predictable footing for years to come.

Leave a Reply