At Tuesday’s meeting of the Brattleboro Selectboard, Town Manager John Potter unveiled a plan to the public that he and the board have been tinkering with in executive session for a number of meetings: sell the Municipal Center and lease the Holstein Building instead, if Town Meeting allows it. Town offices would then be moved down to the new location after renovations were undertaken on the new place.
Their ballpark calculations show some potential savings in the short term. The public, for the most part, wondered at what additional costs and implications weren’t being considered, such as:
– Why lease a property?
– What if the Municipal Center doesn’t sell and it sits vacant?
– What if it gets sold and torn down?
– What’s the real value of the Municipal Center, and is it less than the Town is hoping?
– Over the long-term, the costs of leasing could be as much as the cost of repairs
– What are the actual costs of repairs to the Municipal Center?
– Why break up the convenience of the courthouses, town offices, and library being near one another?
One of the more interesting arguments was that of sovereignty? What does Brattleboro give up by becoming a tenant? It’s not impossible to image the owners of the building selling it at some point, and it wouldn’t be unusual these days for a hedge fund or out of state interest to buy it if it did go on sale. What happens to Brattleboro if we lose the control that comes with owning a property?
Some mentioned the value of having a central, easy to access location for Town business.
It was pointed out that the terms state the rent to go up by 3% a year for the first ten years of the lease agreement.
There were questions of public access, and requiring people to navigate Dysfunction Junction on foot and in cars to get to and from the building. Details of the lease show a reduced number of parking spaces for town business and only one accessible parking space. (While watching, I wondered if people would start parking in the Co-op lot and walking over. )
The public had to remind the Town and board that their planning to move out would impact the other tenants in the Municipal Center. The Brattleboro Historical Society thanked the town for decades of a close partnership, and told them how great it is for the public to be able to go from BHS to the Town Clerk’s office or Planning offices quickly and easily while doing research.
BHS and others also reminded the selectboard that BCTV is also wired into the building. A former BCTV board member cautioned the Town that they could lose live broadcasts if they goto another building.
A small number of the public supported exploring the idea. A realtor encouraged the board to sign the papers if they want to old the property until Town Meeting. Dick Degray said he didn’t like old buildings, downplayed nostalgia and history, and thought it would be easier for him to walk to meetings.
In the end, the board unanimously said they wanted to go forward with paying to hold the property until Town Meeting. The Town Meeting gets to decide if the Town can sell the building. If no, the move is off and planning for renovations need to begin.
Expect some “informational” meetings from those in favor of the plan in the new year.
Disclosure: I’m helping BHS with exhibits; this is my own personal opinion.
Image shows a person saying “I’ve decided I want to sell our home and move down by the railroad tracks into a rental, in a part of town no one ever goes to, separated from downtown by a dangerous intersection and a park full of needles.”







