State Ballot Measures To Protect Rights

Did you get your ballot yet? Two state ballot measures are up for a vote.

The first, Proposal 3, is all about collective bargaining. It would become a state constitutional right to organize or join a labor union for the purpose of collective bargaining.

The other, Proposal 4 is about making it clear that everyone has equal protections under the law. It prohibits the denial of rights to an individual based on their race, ethnicity, sex, religion, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, or national origin.

A majority of state voters will need to approve them to get them into the state constitution.

To me, these seem pretty obvious and basic, and it is a bit surprising we’re just getting to this in 2026. Better late than never, I suppose.

I hope to see these approved by great margins.  As a co-owner I can’t form a union at our business, but I want others to be able to throughout the state. As a white CIS male my rights have been privileged in society, at the expense of others, and I’m not really “free” unless everyone else is, too. Equal protections seems like the least we could do.

If all it takes is filling in the correct box on a ballot, it might be the easiest civil rights action you’ll ever take.

Comments | 10

  • It doesn't say you don't have to join the union, it makes it sound like you have to join!

    No one wants to be forced to join a union.
    No one wants to be forced to pay union dues.
    This law sounds pretty vague to me, and I will vote NO.
    ____________________________________________________________
    PROPOSAL 3
    Sec. 1. PURPOSE
    This proposal would amend the Constitution of the State of Vermont to
    provide that the citizens of the State have a right to collectively bargain.
    Sec. 2. Article 23 of Chapter I of the Vermont Constitution is added to read:
    Article 23. [Right to collectively bargain]
    That employees have a right to organize
    or join
    a labor organization for the
    purpose of collectively bargaining with their employer through an exclusive
    representative of their choosing for the purpose of negotiating wages, hours,
    and
    working conditions
    and to protect their economic welfare
    and safety in the workplace.
    Therefore, no law shall be adopted that interferes with, negates, or
    diminishes the right of employees to collectively bargain with respect to wages,
    hours,
    and other terms
    and conditions of employment
    and workplace safety, or
    that prohibits the application or execution of an agreement between an
    employer
    and a labor organization
    representing the employer’s employees
    that
    requires membership in the labor organization as a condition of employment.

  • Vote No on Prop 4

    “The other, Proposal 4 is about making it clear that everyone has equal protections under the law. It prohibits the denial of rights to an individual based on their race, ethnicity, sex, religion, disability, sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression, or national origin.”

    From the actual wording:
    “Nothing in this Article shall be interpreted or applied to prevent the adoption or implementation of measures intended to provide equality of treatment and opportunity for members of groups that have historically been subject to discrimination.”

    Prop 4 would plainly make it a constitutional requirement to give preference to whomever is declared a group “historically subject to discrimination”. This is one hell of a carve-out that enshrine “subjective” into the “subject”.

    In PlainSpeak: Straight White Men should not apply. Everybody else to the front of the line.

  • RESPONDING TO Submitted by annikee on October 10, "it makes it sound like you have to join" NO IT DOESN'T

    Therefore, no law shall be adopted that
    ( interferes with, negates, or diminishes the right of employees to
    collectively bargain with respect to wages,
    hours, and other terms and conditions of employment
    and workplace safety,)
    —or—
    that prohibits (the application) —or—
    execution of an agreement between an employer and a labor organization
    representing the employer’s employees that
    requires membership in the labor organization as a condition of employment.

    Therefore, no law shall be adopted that prohibits
    execution of an agreement between an employer and a labor organization
    representing the employer’s employees that
    requires membership in the labor organization as a condition of employment.

    No law shall be adopted that prohibits requiring membership in the labor organization
    as a condition of employment.

    Double negative! “no law” and “prohibits”.
    Delete the double negative and you have a law shall be adopted requiring membership
    in the labor organization as a condition of employment.

  • Legislature's attorneys should be fired! IS THIS THE DOUBLE NEGATIVE DECEPTION?

    “Therefore, +++++++++no law shall be adopted that++++++++ interferes with, negates, or diminishes the right of employees to collectively bargain with respect to wages, hours,and other terms and conditions of employment and workplace safety, +++++++++++++ or that prohibits the application or execution of an agreement +++++++++++ between an employer and a labor organization representing the employer’s employees that requires membership in the labor organization as a condition of employment.

    Now, take out the double negative, change “no law shall be adopted”
    to “law shall be adopted” and
    take out “prohibits the application” to “allows the application”
    and you get a law that will be adopted to allow requiring membership in a union?

    THE DOUBLE NEGATIVE DECEPTION IS CONTRACT LAW 101

    Double negative deception in proposals and contracts refers to the deliberate or accidental use of two negative words within a single provision to reverse its meaning, often hiding restrictive terms or creating costly loopholes. While standard grammar dictates that two negatives cancel each other out to create a positive statement, in legal and business agreements, they are frequently used to confuse readers, obscure risks, or shift liabilities.
    Here is a breakdown of how this deception works, where it commonly hides, and how to spot it.

    🔍 How the Deception Works

    A double negative shifts an explicit obligation or right into a conditional or conditional-reverse framework. It forces the reader’s brain to do extra cognitive work, making it easy to misinterpret the true intent during a quick review.
    • The Clear Version: “The Vendor is liable for all system downtime.”
    • The Deceptive Version: “The Vendor shall not be held liable for any downtime, unless such downtime is not caused by routine maintenance.”
    In the deceptive version, the double negative (not liable unless not caused by) creates an ambiguous layer of proof. It subtly shifts the burden onto the client to prove exactly what kind of maintenance occurred before liability can even be discussed.

    📌 Common Areas Where Double Negatives Hide

    1. Scope of Work (SOW) and Exclusions

    Contractors may use double negatives to blur the lines of what is actually included in the price.
    • Example: “No services not explicitly listed in Appendix A shall be performed.”
    • The Reality: This is a roundabout way of saying, “We will only do what is in Appendix A.” However, the phrasing is intentionally restrictive and designed to make adding necessary, implied tasks into a costly “change order.”

    2. Indemnification and Liability Limits

    This is the most high-risk area for double-negative deception, as parties try to escape financial responsibility for mistakes.
    • Example: “Neither party shall be unprotected against claims, except where negligence is not absent.”
    • The Reality: The phrase “negligence is not absent” means negligence is present. The double negative creates a confusing puzzle during a crisis, delaying accountability and increasing legal fees just to interpret the sentence.

    3. Termination and Renewal Clauses

    Automatic renewals (often called “Evergreen clauses”) frequently employ this tactic to trap clients into contract extensions.
    • Example: “This agreement shall not terminate unless notice of non-renewal is not received 90 days prior.”
    • The Reality: The confusing placement of negatives makes it easy to miss the deadline, automatically locking you into another contract term because you misread the required action.

    🛠️ How to Neutralize Double Negatives

    To protect your business from these hidden traps during contract reviews, use these red-flag strategies:
    • The “Cross-Out” Rule: When you spot two negative words (such as not, un-, non-, except, unless, fail to), temporarily cross both of them out to see what the sentence actually means in plain English.
    • Insist on Active Affirmations: Reject convoluted clauses. Rewrite them using active, positive language (e.g., change “It is not uncommon for deadlines to be missed without penalty” to “The Vendor may miss deadlines without penalty”).
    • Watch for “Unless” and “Except”: These words function as structural negatives. When paired with words like no, never, or prohibited, they instantly create a double-negative trap.

  • O The Pain

    Good grief CRIS ERICSON, you seem to be incapable of logic, or willfully trying to make something out of nothing to get attention.

  • ChatGPT for and against Annikee

    Annikee, ChatGPT agrees with you about the double negative BUT
    here is the rest of what ChatGPT writes when the proposal is cut and paste into it: “Its wording is legally dense, but the negatives are grammatically consistent.
    The more substantive question is whether voters understand that the amendment would do more than recognize collective bargaining: it would also constitutionally protect certain agreements requiring union membership as a condition of employment. That is the provision I would focus on when deciding how to vote.”

  • No Chat GPT, please.

    WARNING

    We don’t allow AI generated Chat GPT BS on this site. Be original or be blocked.

    I will start deleting things if I see them or am alerted to them, and if I have to delete too much, I will ban the person who can’t behave.

    STOP NOW!

Leave a Reply